A question for all the teen guys out there?

Hey this is a question for all the teen guys out there. If you saw a tall, pretty, athletic, (ok, a size 3), shy, smart girl, would you consider her attractive? Or are you attracted to petite, thin (size 0) popular, ditzy girls? I am of the former and it seems that a lot of guys like me, but since I'm shy they don't really approach me! Tell me your opinion and why you think maybe guys wouldn't like me?